I made a freaking mens shirt!! Negroni by Colette Patterns.

So there I was, on a Saturday morning, saying to Mr. Guy “I really want to make you something, but don’t know what yet”. I have fabric for another Newcastle Cardigan (my first one here) but TBH I dislike the fabric – but he chose it and loves it so I will make it up. I have fabric for some Jedediah Trousers but haven’t traced the pattern yet. I also recently bought the Negroni Shirt but didn’t have any fabric for it – I always have a had time finding/buying/imagining “shirting” so have never bought any.

And then, I realised that of course I could use the linen I had set aside for shorts, for a shirt. Therefore, I can present: my first mens shirt.


I really did think that this was going to take me several days, even two weeks, as I carefully made a muslin and slaved over the tailoring details of a menshirt. I find it odd that I can say this took me only two half days, including researching by reading the Mens Shirt Sewalong by Male Pattern Boldness, and downloading David Coffin’s e-book on Shirtmaking (use the code SHARE20 for 20% discount over the next few days).

I actually didn’t do a muslin at all (because I didn’t have any spare fabric!!) but I did make sure the yoke fit well. This was the first version – I measured his back between both shoulder points (I use the tip of the acromion) then measured the pattern pieces and starting with a small:


It’s a bit tricky to tell because his tshirt doesn’t fit right on the shoulders, but the size small yoke wasn’t nearly wide enough – I unfolded the seam allowance and it was about perfect. That actually gave me exactly the medium size:


Other than that, I also added 1.5cm to the shoulder seam on the yoke, and cut away a bit at the neckline-shoulder corner. I held up my front and back pattern pieces (traced to a size medium, which matched his chest and waist measurements) and they seemed to fit well; I also measured his arms to make sure the sleeves would be long enough. Then I just got cracking!


I did make sure I took my time, getting the stitching square, my top- and edgestitching perfect, etc. I did have a problem with the collar being waaaaay too short, which confused me until I remembered that 1.5cm I added, and the fabric I took away at the neck-shoulder corner – this added a total of 6cm onto the neck seam, so I re-cut the collar (so I had no more mishaps like this dress, where the collar ended up being crazy ugly short. I wore this twice then took it to the op shop).

The good thing about sewing for others is that I really take my time, making sure I unpick and fix things that I would often let fly if I was sewing for myself (the bad thing is that sometimes I’m too scared to start; I’ve had some black merino to make my mum some leggings for almost a YEAR now). For this shirt I only needed my quick-unpick three times which is pretty good for me as my haste often breeds mistakes.


I must say, I am so incredibly happy with this shirt. It’s one of the best (if not THE best) thing I have ever made. The whole thing in constructed without an overlocker or handsewing, yet there are no exposed seams; the instructions for sewing the yoke are brilliant and easily enclose all the seams (why doesn’t everyone use this method? Gertie why does your shirtwaist dress involve so much hand sewing??), and the shoulder, sleeve and side seams are all flat felled.

I did a proper sleeve placket which went together very easily, and I narrow hemmed the bottom without the special foot. After trying it several times and then being shown another method by Mrs. C, I’ve come to realise that the hem foot is basically a gimmick, and it’s much easier just doing it with the normal foot; folding as you go, then trimming and folding again, leaving the iron for the very end.

ImageI probably should have trimmed the neck/facing corner better as it isn’t pressing crisply


The inside is as pretty as the outside πŸ™‚



(oops I took a photo of the uglier side – I forgot to pull the wee lever down on my buttonhole foot so there’s extra stitching)

You will have noticed the polka dots – I couldn’t help myself! I asked him whether he wanted the facing to be self-fabric, or the polka dot fabric I had left over from my latest Cambie (asked in a very leading way), and I decided to do the cuffs the same. I didn’t realise until later on that part of the facing would be visible when the shirt folds open at the top – but I like it! As Mr. Guy pointed out, it almost looks like a little bow tie. I also love the flash of spots when he rolls up the sleeves.


It fits extremely well, for having basically no alterations from the pattern. It’s a slim fitting pattern which is good for my slim-fitting husband. I’m glad it has no darts in it because I’ve taken David Coffins words to heart for a mens shirt – that darts are “merely evidence of ill-cut side seams” (this doesn’t apply in womenswear, obviously). Even the length of the sleeves and body is perfect – he can easily tuck it in and it’s not too long to be worn untucked. We decided to leave off the pockets as it looked so good without them.


Mr. Guy is also very happy with his new shirt – he’s already requested another “in parchment coloured linen with this exact texture”, not seeming to understand that it’s uncommon to find textured linen. I also asked him if he’d ever wear “crazy patterns” (although I don’t think he could quite pull this or this off) and he said “only if I match what you’re wearing” – ohh, be still my beating heart! I’ve been waiting to hear that ever since I found out about this couple who have worn matching outfits for the last 35 years (this is my favourite – I want a dress just like that!!).

You may have already recognised the fabric this shirt is out of; yes, we already have one matching outfit!

ImageCouldn’t quite get the photo even as the camera was balanced on a spherical boulder.

So, there’s my first foray into mens shirt-making. Now that I have a pattern that fits (and it fits WELL), I’ll be able to easily make up more shirts. IΒ  have some fabric on the way, with which I’m planning to make a shirtwaist dress, so I might buy more to make us another matching outfit.



Pattern: Negroni by Colette Patterns, $18

Fabric: Navy linen, $3/m from sale = $6, plus polka dots leftover from a dress

Notions: Navy buttons, $4.20, interfacing and thread from stash

Total: $10.40 as is, $38.40 including pattern


Photos were taken at the Koutu Boulders.


26 thoughts on “I made a freaking mens shirt!! Negroni by Colette Patterns.

    • I’d better still enjoy it because I’m going to make a top for my dads birthday, and I think I just promised my mum I’d make her a skirt (+/- a top as well). I already have a pair of leggings I have to make for her

  1. Wow! That shirt looks so professional, like it came right out of a fashion magazine! I think the details make it: the polka dots and the impeccable fit. Congrats: it’s a beauty!

    • Thank you!! I kept looking at him wearing it yesterday and being surprised that I had actually made it! Hopefully that kind of attention to detail flows through to my own clothes

  2. I love your/his shirt! Sewing for my man is very satisfying. Isn’t it funny how when you finish something and they like it, they make requests? Great job. Now you will need to constantly search for shirting.

    • Yeah, yet another fabric to start collecting, whoops! At least it’s usually nice stable fabrics for menswear. It was nice that he was excited as I was for this to be finished.

  3. It turned out great! Love the polka dots, don’t think my boyfriend would appreciate them so you are one lucky girl. I love sewing men’s shirts but don’t really do it very often. I’ve had fabric for another one for my boyfriend for nearly a year now and still need to start.

    • Maybe you could trick him? I unwittingly tricked Mr. Guy into these polka dots, and he doesn’t hate them! I don’t know how often I’ll make these, although I like him wearing shirts so if I have the fabric, maybe they wont be too infrequent.

      • I have managed to trick him into a reddish shirt that he wears often (his comfort zone is blue, black and grey) but I fear polka dots or any other print that isn’t a stripe will be a bridge too far. I could give it a try though… Who knows?

  4. This looks so impressive! The fit looks great & the polka dot details are ace! I’d love to make something for my husband one day – though I have so little sewing time right now I think that day is a long way off! These photos are lovely too – they make me want to see the sea.

    • We’re remarkably lucky in NZ tha the sea is never very far away, and most cities are based near the sea or a major river. If I didn’t have much time for sewing I don’t think I’d make him anything either!

  5. Great job! The shirt fits absolutely perfectly! I like the polka-dots peaking out. I always try to persuade my guy for contrast facings but he always says no… Maybe I should start offering something different than hot pink…
    And matching outfits? So cool! I must start brainwashing my husband…

    • I’m really surprised that it fit him so well straight out of the envelope – I can’t see any major fit issues (although that might change with another type of fabric, I don’t think it will). As I said above – maybe try and trick him, by saying it’s “just the facing will be this other fabric because I don’t have enough of the main fabric” and then by the time he realises, it’ll be too late and he’ll be in love

      • Or maybe just not say anything and just make a contrasting facing, and then challenge him to not wear the shirt I have just spent hours of my time, and liters of my sweat and the occasional drop of blood on, just for him… πŸ˜‰

  6. That fit is fab and it looks shop bought (except better made!) I’m inspired to give this a go, so need to do some thinking about the facings; i’m a bright colour /polka dot /stripe kinda girl = husband is a black /blue /boring color kinda guy so we struggle to agree. i made the Jedidiah shorts for him and used a kids giraffe print for inside the pockets = he said he was okay with it as no one could see it however i keep pointing it out to everyone especially when our 4 year old is wearing his giraffe shorts and they match πŸ™‚

    • Even stripes would look cool, but be low key enough! And I think for it to be striking you just need a contrast fabric which doesn’t necessarily need to be bright or bold. I love that he matches your 4 year old πŸ˜€

  7. Great job! Fab fabric. Who doesn’t love a navy mens shirt right?
    I made up this pattern a few years ago, and remember that there was something about the yoke construction that was bothering me. I think there was a little hole left open in the inside seam, wich wasn’t possible to close or anything. It wasn’t visible, but if I know it’s there, that is definitely a reason to lose sleep over lol.

    Your matching outfits are cute, for this one time… Really. That’s about as far as you can go. You get that right? Hahaha! That elderly couple, OMG! Please don’t go there! please?

    • You’re probably thinking of when you do the shoulder seams of the yoke, you can’t do them fully all the way – you end up leaving 1cm or so, depending on how acrobatic you can be.

      This kind of “matching outfit” isn’t even noticible though D: I have plans for some fabric that include a tie for Mr. Guy that matches me but I don’t know how often that would get worn. I did make him a tie that matched a ball dress of mine in university which was cool! But yeah, I don’t think he would really let me get away with THAT much matching, unless it was dress-up.

  8. Pingback: The never ending (linen) story: La Sylphide blouse |

  9. That’s a beautifully made shirt and handsome hubby looks fabulous in it! My fellow would never ever wear (a) polka dots or (b) anything that matches me so I’m enjoying seeing it on you!

  10. Pingback: Plaid Flannel Negroni | tworandomwords

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s